*** This is ocra 1.4.0 (compiled on Tue Feb 14 10:27:10 2017)
*** For more information on ocra see <https://es.fbk.eu/tools/ocra/>
*** For bug reports, or any comment, please send an email to <ocra@list.fbk.eu>.
*** Copyright (c) 2013, Fondazione Bruno Kessler

*** This version of ocra is linked to NuSMV 2.6.0.
*** For more information on NuSMV see <http://nusmv.fbk.eu>
*** or email to <nusmv-users@list.fbk.eu>.
*** Copyright (C) 2010-2014, Fondazione Bruno Kessler

*** This version of ocra is linked to the CUDD library version 2.4.1
*** Copyright (c) 1995-2004, Regents of the University of Colorado

*** This version of ocra is linked to the MiniSat SAT solver. 
*** See http://minisat.se/MiniSat.html
*** Copyright (c) 2003-2006, Niklas Een, Niklas Sorensson
*** Copyright (c) 2007-2010, Niklas Sorensson

Warning: in the refinement of component SensorPedalPosition the following ports are not connected:
input port mechanical_pedal_pos
output port electrical_pedal_pos
Warning: in the refinement of component SwitchGate the following ports are not connected:
input port cmd_in_1
input port cmd_in_2
input port validity_1
input port validity_2
output port cmd_out
Warning: in the refinement of component OrGate the following ports are not connected:
input port in_1
input port in_2
output port out
:START:benchmarking ocra_check_refinement
:START:Check Refinement

Checking refinement of component: wbs_arch4
  The refinement is correct

Checking refinement of component: ControlSystem
  The refinement is correct

Checking refinement of component: BSCU
  The refinement is correct

Checking refinement of component: Channel
  The refinement is correct

Checking refinement of component: MonitorSystem

Checking refinement of component: CommandSystem
  The refinement is correct

Checking refinement of component: WheelPairCommandSystem
  The refinement is correct

Checking refinement of component: AlternateCommandCalculator

Checking refinement of component: NormalCommandCalculator

Checking refinement of component: AntiSkidCommandFacility

Checking refinement of component: BrakeCommandFacility

Checking refinement of component: OrGate

Checking refinement of component: SwitchGate

Checking refinement of component: PhysicalSystem
  The refinement is correct

Checking refinement of component: HydraulicPump

Checking refinement of component: ShutoffValve

Checking refinement of component: Accumulator

Checking refinement of component: SelectorValve

Checking refinement of component: NormalBrakeSystem
  The refinement is correct

Checking refinement of component: MeterValve

Checking refinement of component: AlternateBrakeSystem
  The refinement is correct

Checking refinement of component: AntiskidShutoffValve

Checking refinement of component: WheelBrake
  The refinement is correct

Checking refinement of component: HydraulicFuse

Checking refinement of component: HydraulicPiston

Checking refinement of component: BrakeActuator

Checking refinement of component: Wheel

Checking refinement of component: AdditionGate

Checking refinement of component: Sensor

Checking refinement of component: SensorPedalPosition
  
  Summary: everything is OK.
  :STOP:Check Refinement
  :TIME:Check Refinement = 54.0280 secs.
  
  ********   WARNING   ********
  The initial states set of the finite state machine is empty.
  This might make results of model checking not trustable.
  ******** END WARNING ********
  -- specification TRUE  is true
  Entailment tighten_W_command_creation_normal_8_at_CommandSystem: OK 
  -- specification (!( G (((((power & ground_speed > 0) & (!wheel_rolling_1 | !wheel_rolling_2)) <-> alternate_command_calculator.as_cmd_out) & (((power & electrical_pedal_pos) & ((ground_speed > 0 & wheel_rolling_1) | ground_speed = 0)) <-> normal_command_calculator_1.brake_as_cmd)) & (((power & electrical_pedal_pos) & ((ground_speed > 0 & wheel_rolling_2) | ground_speed = 0)) <-> normal_command_calculator_2.brake_as_cmd))) |  G ((!((power & electrical_pedal_pos) & ((ground_speed > 0 & wheel_rolling_2) | ground_speed = 0)) | normal_command_calculator_2.brake_as_cmd) & (!normal_command_calculator_2.brake_as_cmd | ((power & electrical_pedal_pos) & ((ground_speed > 0 & wheel_rolling_2) | ground_speed = 0)))))  is true
  Entailment tighten_W_commands_creation_dup_at_WheelPairCommandSystem: OK 
  
  ********   WARNING   ********
  The initial states set of the finite state machine is empty.
  This might make results of model checking not trustable.
  ******** END WARNING ********
  -- specification TRUE  is true
  Entailment tighten_W_expected_behavior_brake_as_cmd_8_at_BSCU: OK 
  
  ********   WARNING   ********
  The initial states set of the finite state machine is empty.
  This might make results of model checking not trustable.
  ******** END WARNING ********
  -- specification TRUE  is true
  Entailment tighten_W_never_inadvertent_braking_of_wheel_8_at_wbs_arch4: OK 
  
  ********   WARNING   ********
  The initial states set of the finite state machine is empty.
  This might make results of model checking not trustable.
  ******** END WARNING ********
  -- specification (!( G (wheel_brake_8.braking_force > 0 -> ((brake_as_cmd_8 & (shutoff_valve.hyd_pressure_out > 0 & system_validity)) | ((mechanical_pedal_pos_R & !as_cmd_pair_4_8) & (shutoff_valve.hyd_pressure_out = 0 | !system_validity))))) |  G (!(wheel_brake_8.braking_force > 0) | ((brake_as_cmd_8 & (shutoff_valve.hyd_pressure_out > 0 & system_validity)) | ((mechanical_pedal_pos_R & !as_cmd_pair_4_8) & (shutoff_valve.hyd_pressure_out = 0 | !system_validity)))))  is true
  Entailment tighten_W_braking_wheel_8_implies_cmd_dup_at_PhysicalSystem: OK 
  -- specification (!( G (mechanical_pedal_pos <-> electrical_pedal_pos)) |  G ((!mechanical_pedal_pos | electrical_pedal_pos) & (!electrical_pedal_pos | mechanical_pedal_pos)))  is true
  Entailment tighten_W_pedal_position_translation_dup_at_SensorPedalPosition: OK 
  
  ********   WARNING   ********
  The initial states set of the finite state machine is empty.
  This might make results of model checking not trustable.
  ******** END WARNING ********
  -- specification (!(( G (validity_1 -> (cmd_out <-> cmd_in_1)) &  G ((!validity_1 & validity_2) -> (cmd_out <-> cmd_in_2))) &  G ((!validity_1 & !validity_2) -> cmd_out = FALSE)) | (( G (!validity_1 | (cmd_out <-> cmd_in_1)) &  G (!(!validity_1 & validity_2) | (cmd_out <-> cmd_in_2))) &  G (!(!validity_1 & !validity_2) | cmd_out = FALSE)))  is true
  Entailment tighten_W_switch_behavior_at_SwitchGate: OK 
  -- specification (!( G (bscu.system_validity <-> (((((((((((((power_1 | power_2) & ((electrical_pedal_pos_L & ((ground_speed > 0 & wheel_rolling_1) | ground_speed = 0)) <-> bscu.brake_as_cmd_1)) & ((electrical_pedal_pos_L & ((ground_speed > 0 & wheel_rolling_2) | ground_speed = 0)) <-> bscu.brake_as_cmd_2)) & ((electrical_pedal_pos_R & ((ground_speed > 0 & wheel_rolling_3) | ground_speed = 0)) <-> bscu.brake_as_cmd_3)) & ((electrical_pedal_pos_R & ((ground_speed > 0 & wheel_rolling_4) | ground_speed = 0)) <-> bscu.brake_as_cmd_4)) & ((electrical_pedal_pos_L & ((ground_speed > 0 & wheel_rolling_5) | ground_speed = 0)) <-> bscu.brake_as_cmd_5)) & ((electrical_pedal_pos_L & ((ground_speed > 0 & wheel_rolling_6) | ground_speed = 0)) <-> bscu.brake_as_cmd_6)) & ((electrical_pedal_pos_R & ((ground_speed > 0 & wheel_rolling_7) | ground_speed = 0)) <-> bscu.brake_as_cmd_7)) & ((electrical_pedal_pos_R & ((ground_speed > 0 & wheel_rolling_8) | ground_speed = 0)) <-> bscu.brake_as_cmd_8)) & ((ground_speed > 0 & (!wheel_rolling_1 | !wheel_rolling_5)) <-> bscu.as_cmd_pair_1_5)) & ((ground_speed > 0 & (!wheel_rolling_2 | !wheel_rolling_6)) <-> bscu.as_cmd_pair_2_6)) & ((ground_speed > 0 & (!wheel_rolling_3 | !wheel_rolling_7)) <-> bscu.as_cmd_pair_3_7)) & ((ground_speed > 0 & (!wheel_rolling_4 | !wheel_rolling_8)) <-> bscu.as_cmd_pair_4_8)))) |  G (!bscu.system_validity | (((((((((((((power_1 | power_2) & ((electrical_pedal_pos_L & ((ground_speed > 0 & wheel_rolling_1) | ground_speed = 0)) <-> bscu.brake_as_cmd_1)) & ((electrical_pedal_pos_L & ((ground_speed > 0 & wheel_rolling_2) | ground_speed = 0)) <-> bscu.brake_as_cmd_2)) & ((electrical_pedal_pos_R & ((ground_speed > 0 & wheel_rolling_3) | ground_speed = 0)) <-> bscu.brake_as_cmd_3)) & ((electrical_pedal_pos_R & ((ground_speed > 0 & wheel_rolling_4) | ground_speed = 0)) <-> bscu.brake_as_cmd_4)) & ((electrical_pedal_pos_L & ((ground_speed > 0 & wheel_rolling_5) | ground_speed = 0)) <-> bscu.brake_as_cmd_5)) & ((electrical_pedal_pos_L & ((ground_speed > 0 & wheel_rolling_6) | ground_speed = 0)) <-> bscu.brake_as_cmd_6)) & ((electrical_pedal_pos_R & ((ground_speed > 0 & wheel_rolling_7) | ground_speed = 0)) <-> bscu.brake_as_cmd_7)) & ((electrical_pedal_pos_R & ((ground_speed > 0 & wheel_rolling_8) | ground_speed = 0)) <-> bscu.brake_as_cmd_8)) & ((ground_speed > 0 & (!wheel_rolling_1 | !wheel_rolling_5)) <-> bscu.as_cmd_pair_1_5)) & ((ground_speed > 0 & (!wheel_rolling_2 | !wheel_rolling_6)) <-> bscu.as_cmd_pair_2_6)) & ((ground_speed > 0 & (!wheel_rolling_3 | !wheel_rolling_7)) <-> bscu.as_cmd_pair_3_7)) & ((ground_speed > 0 & (!wheel_rolling_4 | !wheel_rolling_8)) <-> bscu.as_cmd_pair_4_8))))  is true
  Entailment tighten_W_system_validity_dup_at_ControlSystem: OK 
  -- specification (!( G (out <-> (in_1 | in_2))) |  G ((!out | (in_1 | in_2)) & (!(in_1 | in_2) | out)))  is true
  Entailment tighten_W_or_behavior_at_OrGate: OK 
  -- specification (!( G (((power & electrical_pedal_pos_R) & ((ground_speed > 0 & wheel_rolling_8) | ground_speed = 0)) <-> command_sys.brake_as_cmd_8)) |  G ((!((power & electrical_pedal_pos_R) & ((ground_speed > 0 & wheel_rolling_8) | ground_speed = 0)) | command_sys.brake_as_cmd_8) & (!command_sys.brake_as_cmd_8 | ((power & electrical_pedal_pos_R) & ((ground_speed > 0 & wheel_rolling_8) | ground_speed = 0)))))  is true
  Entailment tighten_W_command_creation_normal_8_at_Channel: OK 
  -- specification (!( G (power <-> monitor_sys.bscu_validity)) |  G (!monitor_sys.bscu_validity | power))  is true
  Entailment tighten_W_always_validity_at_Channel: OK 
  
  All validation properties have been checked. 
